Subject
Mill, John Stuart, 1806-1873. Examination of Sir William Hamilton's philosophy Books
Best books
George Grote
Review of the Work of Mr John Stuart Mill Entitled, 'Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy.'
"Review of the Work of Mr. John Stuart Mill Entitled, 'Examination of Sir William Hamilton's Philosophy'" by George Grote is a philosophical critique written in the late 19th century. The work provides a thorough examination of John Stuart Mill's analysis of Sir William Hamilton’s philosophical doctrines, particularly focusing on the relativity of human knowledge, arguments surrounding metaphysics, and the distinction between various philosophical perspectives. This critical discourse is particularly relevant for students and scholars of philosophy, highlighting the contrasting views of two significant thinkers in the field. The opening of the work introduces Sir William Hamilton's influential role in Edinburgh's philosophical landscape and outlines the context of Mill's critical examination. Grote begins by acknowledging the complexity and depth of Mill's writing, emphasizing that while Hamilton has indeed shaped modern thought, his theories invite scrutiny. The text highlights Mill's examination of Hamilton's assertions about the relativity of knowledge and the inconsistencies within Hamilton's views. It also indicates that Mill's criticism aims not only to dismantle Hamilton's positions but also to construct nuanced arguments in favor of his philosophical propositions, setting the stage for a thorough exploration of their ideas throughout the rest of the book.
Henry Longueville Mansel
The Philosophy of the Conditioned
"The Philosophy of the Conditioned" by Henry Longueville Mansel is a philosophical treatise written in the mid-19th century. The work focuses on examining the philosophical currents of the time, particularly critiquing the ideas of Sir William Hamilton and John Stuart Mill regarding the concepts of the conditioned and unconditioned. Mansel delves into the nature of consciousness, knowledge, and the limits of human understanding, engaging deeply with metaphysical concepts that relate to our perception of reality. The opening portion of the text introduces Mansel's motivation for writing, which stems from his reflections on a previous anonymous review of Hamilton’s philosophy that he felt required defense. He outlines the philosophical debate on conditioned and unconditioned existence, invoking Plato to discuss the aspirational journey of reason toward the unconditioned as a means of better understanding the nature of truth. Both the complexities of consciousness and the challenge of reconciling knowledge with the divine are addressed, setting the stage for a nuanced discussion on how humans engage with abstract principles and the implications for belief in a personal deity. The philosophical tensions established in the introduction suggest a foundational exploration of faith, reason, and their intersections with human cognition.
Recently surfaced classics